leadership

Pastors and Directors

In addition to the pastors and directors listed below, Mt. Pisgah also has three lay-overseers/pastors, 12 deacons, and 12 trustees to ensure the ministry of preaching/teaching and prayer can continue unhindered.

  • Robb Barlow, Senior Pastor

    Robb is the main teacher and preacher. He is from Georgetown, Kentucky and is married to Karen. He has been the senior pastor of Mt. Pisgah since 1987. Robb was an Indiana Army National Guard Chaplain and retired in 2013. He enjoys the Kentucky countryside, riding horses, and coaching his grandchildren. Robb holds a Bachelor of Arts in History, an Master of Arts in Education, a Master of Divinity, and a Doctor of Ministry.

  • Nick Coulston, Associate pastor

    Nick and Katie were married in November of 2013 and have one daughter. Nick coordinates the media for both services, teaches and preaches, is the Sunday school superintendent, and is a chaplain at Major Hospital. Nick holds a Bachelor of Arts in English, a Master of Divinity, and a Doctor of Educational Ministry from the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.

  • Dan Theobald, Youth and Family Director

    Dan and Mariah were married in 2004 and have five children. He received his Bachelor of Science in Education and taught middle school students for 10 years before transitioning to full-time ministry. Dan oversees Children's Church in both worship services, organizes our mid-week programming, family outings, Vacation Bible School, and church camp. He is currently pursuing a Master of Ministry at Indianapolis Reformed Seminary.

  • Kari Justice, outreach and Assimilation Director

    Kari and Jordan were married in 2011 and have three children. She received her Bachelor of Science in Nursing and continues to practice while serving in vocational ministry since 2019. She has a Master of Ministry in Youth and Family from Wesley Seminary. Kari's passion is for seeing the lost be saved and the saved be discipled.

  • T.j. Nolley, Contemporary Music Director

    T.J. and Cassie were married in June 2018 and have one son, Parker. T.J. is a third-grade teacher at Coulston Elementary School. He received his Bachelor of Science in Education from IUPUC. T.J. has a passion for playing drums and leading others closer to Christ.

  • Debbie Ryhal, Traditional Music Director

    Debbie is the worship leader for our traditional worship service. She is a talented organist and director. She earned her Bachelor's degree at the University of Indianapolis and Master's degree at Indiana University. She is married to Greg, and they have two children and six grandchildren.